Criterium	Carlisle	Barieuph	RedBeastMage	Total Score
Theme	5	9	10	24
Creativity	33	37	36	106
Remix	25	22	22	69
Production	8	11	5	24
Total	71	79	73	223

Comments

Barieuph

Theme - I like what you did mixing two themes that are pretty unsung.

Remix - The use of both themes individually sounds great, however when they are combined they seem to step on each other's toes a little bit, perhaps the point of the mix as you said in your blurb, but at times it can be a little unpleasant to the ears.

Creativity - There is no doubt creativity used in this piece, but I feel that a little more attention could have been paid to a few ideas you had. The themes seem a little to fragmented. 

Production - The sound is just a little thin, sounds a bit too much like the SNES days on some of the sounds. 

Redbeastmage

Theme - Hits the theme right on the head. Lesser known game, side characters, and a nice job mixing two character themes together.

Remix - Even when listening to source SPC files, I had a hard time finding the characters music clearly stated in the work. Took me a few passes to really get a feel for the tune from a "remix" standpoint.

Creativity - Nice and well thought out blend of music in here. Very nice, but the quality of sounds hurts the overall ability to hear what is going on.

Production - This remix was lacking alot in the production department. Sounds very midi like in all the instrumentation. Definitely could have used some love and attention in with some fresh samples, especially for the drums.