Criterium	Carlisle	Barieuph	RedBeastMage	Total Score
Theme	3	4	3	10
Creativity	45	39	41	125
Remix	25	22	28	75
Production	13	15	15	43
Total	86	79	87	252

Comments

Barieuph

Theme - I don't think this is an unused theme at all. It's featured on the Piano Collections album and has been remixed by a few people before you. I think there are better choices in from Final Fantasy X, as well as other games that you could have chosen. 

Remix - The remix is solid and I like what has been done, but it's almost as though you've simply transcribed it. 

Creativity - You've done some really creative things with your mix. I like how there are a lot of different sections, but perhaps a keychange or something could have made the theme a little less repetitive, regardless of changes in style. 

Production - I really like the sounds you used and the quality is top notch!

Redbeastmage

Theme - Very easily recognized character, although often overlooked in her first game, sits very important in X-2.

Remix - Really nice work done with her theme. Easily recognized for anyone familiar with FFX. Comes back with different motives throughout the piece giving it real depth.

Creativity - Very nice feel to it, great instrumentation choices. Some parts feel like they drag a bit in the middle, around the three minute mark, but the section transitions following bring the listener right back.

Production - Amazing production going on in this piece. I can find no flaws; a model of how to put a remix together.