Wonderslime	Carlisle	Barieuph	RedBeastMage	Total Score
Theme	15	15	15	15	45
Remix	26	23	26	27	79
Creativity	36	38	40	36	112
Production	14	13	15	12	41
Total	91	89	96	90	277

Comments

Wonderslime

Wow! This is a truly remarkable transformation... you got it exactly right in your description; this sounds exactly like music that might play while the credits are rolling, and despite the carefree nature of the piece, it is extremely easy to pick out the original theme. Well paced; you picked the right tempo... if I had anything negative to say about the melody, it would be the fast notes, which very occasionally seem a tad forced. It would have been nice to see perhaps a few more variations in the reprise (recapitulation? Hahaha, I forget what the terminology is) that begins near the 2:00 mark, but your arrangement is quite satisfying in the end. Good work!

Redbeastmage

Absolutly hit the nail on the head with the theme of the contest. I really felt like this piece still fit the game while it defintly did not still fit its original purpose. On top of that, it has an amazing sound to itself, very unique. I have to say my only real problem was with the panning, because it felt to heavy to the left channel, especially at the start and end when its also only guitar. Aside from that, there is little else for me to add other then to say great work.